All reviewers agreed this paper is well written presenting some interesting novel ideas. Reviewers believe that integrating common knowledge directly into Multi-agent RL training is a nice idea, and suggests some interesting future directions of research. Initially, there were shared concerns and confusion though about a number of issues, most prominently about the matrix game example. After reading and discussing the authors rebuttal though it seems the authors adequately addressed some of the primary concerns, and the general sense is that this paper is solid and of interest to be presented at NeurIPS.